Scudder, Vida Dutton (15 Dec. 1861-9 Oct. 1954), social reformer, writer, and educator, was born Julia Vida Dutton Scudder in Madura, India, the daughter of David Coit Scudder, a Congregationalist missionary, and Harriet Louisa Dutton. Scudder moved to the United States as an infant, following the tragic drowning of her father. For the first few years of her life she lived with her mother and other relatives at the Dutton family home in Auburndale, Massachusetts. Scudder came from two well-established New England families - she was the niece of Horace Scudder, editor of the Atlantic Monthly, and Edward P. Dutton, a publisher. Growing up, Scudder spent several years traveling in Europe with her mother and aunt. Upon her return, she began attending Miss Sanger's school in Boston. She entered Boston's newly established Girls' Latin School in 1878 and earned her B.A. from Smith College in 1884.

Following her graduation from Smith, Scudder traveled to England to become one of the first women to study at Oxford University. At Oxford Scudder attended the last series of lectures by social critic John Ruskin. The lectures by Ruskin inspired Scudder to think critically about social stratification based on class. She realized her own privileged background and felt angered by the social divisions that she saw crystallizing within an increasingly industrialized society. Scudder's growing contempt for such divisions prompted her to begin participating in organized efforts to ameliorate social conditions, and she joined the Salvation Army while in England.

Scudder returned to Boston in 1885 and occupied herself with the activities of several newly organized women's organizations, including the Association of Collegiate Alumnae and the Saturday Morning Club in Boston. While these organizations helped Scudder create a network of professional contacts, they did not speak directly to the questions of social and moral responsibility that interested her. She turned to writing, and after completing a thesis on modern English poets she earned an M.A. from Smith College. In 1887 she accepted a position at Wellesley College to teach English literature.

During the fall of her first year at Wellesley, Scudder met with a small group of Smith alumnae to discuss the establishment of an American settlement house. The settlement idea, which had originated in England as a predominately male venture, appealed to Scudder's desire to work toward tempering class divisions. Settlement workers, mostly white and formally educated, moved into immigrant/working-class neighborhoods to offer cultural and social programs to members of the community. In an article for the Andover Review, "The Place of College Settlements" (Oct. 1892), Scudder wrote, "The amateur settlement expresses that pure and voluntary socialism which many of us feel holds our best and most permanent hope." Scudder believed that college-educated women, trained as both caretakers and intellectuals, had a primary role to play in the development of settlement houses.

By early 1889 Scudder and settlement-house organizers from Smith had expanded their informal association to include women from other colleges. The group opened the first successful American settlement house, located on Rivington Street in New York City, on 1 September 1889--Jane Addams and Ellen Gates Starr opened Hull-House in Chicago two weeks later. Founders of the Rivington Street settlement depended in large part on the financial support of other college-educated women. Such support enabled founders to organize formally into the College Settlements Association (CSA) in 1890. Membership in the CSA grew rapidly, and the organization opened two more settlement houses, Denison House in Boston and the College Settlement in Philadelphia, in 1892. By 1898 the CSA had more than 2,000 members nationwide.

During her tenure with the CSA, Scudder served on the CSA's electoral board and participated actively in the creation of programs at Denison House. She pushed members of the house to become involved with labor issues and in 1903 helped found the Women's Trade Union League. Although she never resided permanently at any of the CSA's houses--teaching duties at Wellesley and a commitment to living with her mother prevented her from doing so--Scudder served as one of the CSA's main spokespersons, publishing numerous articles on social reform and the role of the settlement house in American life.

By 1912 Scudder worried that her affiliation with socialism and other radical forms of politics would harm the CSA's reputation, and she resigned from the organization. Around that time Scudder had come under attack from members of the Wellesley community after having spoken out at a textile strike in Lawrence, Massachusetts. Since the late 1880s Scudder's politics had grown increasingly Leftist. She participated in such organizations as the Society of Christian Socialists, the Christian Social Union, the Episcopal Church Socialist League, and, later, the Intercollegiate Socialist League. In 1911 she joined the Socialist party.

Scudder grounded her socialist beliefs in a foundation of Christian doctrine and Christian faith. She joined the Society of the Companions of the Holy Cross (SCHC), a women's Episcopal organization practicing intercessory prayer, in 1889 and remained active until her death. She also published numerous books on the Catholic tradition. In Socialism and Character (1912) she argues for a spiritual and political union between Marxism and Catholicism.

Retiring from Wellesley in 1928, Scudder spent much of her later life writing. She continued to involve herself with church-related activities, and in the early 1930s she served as the first dean of the School of Christian Ethics, a three-week summer program run by the Church League for Industrial Democracy. In 1937 Scudder published the first volume of her autobiography, On Journey. She published the second volume, My Quest for Reality, in 1952.

Through her writing and organizational work, Scudder encouraged a new generation of middle-class women, college educated and professionally motivated, to bring about social change through settlement-house work and other forms of collective action. The effects of this work were long-lasting, and by the early twentieth century, women made up the majority of settlement workers in the United States. Privately, Scudder lived for thirty-five years with Florence Converse, whom she called her "Comrade and Companion." Scudder died at her home in Wellesley, Massachusetts.

Bibliography

Collections of Scudder's papers are housed in the Wellesley College Archives; the archives of the Society of the Companions of the Holy Cross in South Byfield, Mass.; and the Sophia Smith Collection of the Smith College Library. Other archival sources include the Denison House Papers of the Arthur and Elizabeth Schlesinger Library, Radcliffe College, and the College Settlements Association Papers of the Sophia Smith Collection, Smith College Library. Some of Scudder's books not cited above include The Witness of Denial (1895); The Life of the Spirit in Modern English Poets (1895); Social Ideals in English Letters (1898); Introduction to the Study of English Literature (1901); A Listener in Babel: Being a Series of Imaginary Conversations (1903); Saint Catherine of Siena as Seen in Her Letters (1905); The Disciple of a Saint (1907); Le Morte d'Arthur of Sir Thomas Malory and Its Sources (1917); The Church and the Hour: Reflections of a Socialist Churchwoman (1917); The Social Teachings of the Christian Year (1921); Brother John: A Tale of the First Franciscans (1927); The Franciscan Adventure (1931); The Privilege of Age: Essays Secular and Spiritual (1939); and Father Huntington (1940). Some helpful secondary materials on Scudder are Theresa Corcoran, S.C., Vida Dutton Scudder (1982); Elizabeth Palmer Hutcheson Carrell, "Reflections in a Mirror: The Progressive Woman and the Settlement Experience" (Ph.D. diss., Univ. of Texas at Austin, 1981); and Arthur Mann, Yankee Reformers in an Urban Age (1954). For a discussion of Scudder at Wellesley, see Patricia Ann Palmieri, In Adamless Eden: The Community of Women Faculty at Wellesley (1995). An obituary is in the New York Times, 11 Oct. 1954.

Michelle A. Spinelli

Copyright Notice

Permission is granted to make and distribute verbatim copies of the American National Biography of the Day and Sample Biographies provided that the following statement is preserved on all copies:

From American National Biography, published by Oxford University

Press, Inc., copyright 2000 American Council of Learned Societies.

Further information is available at http://www.anb.org

This site was updated on 30-Apr-25.