In the painting American Gothic, by Grant Wood, a stern father stands with a pitchfork beside his unhappy daughter

The Role of Parents in Courtship
Click here to read reflections about dating from young people in the 1920s Click here to see love letters from the past Click here to read about marriages in the past Click here to read how 'dating' originated Click here to read about when romance became a part of courtship Click here to read about parental involvement in courtship Click here to read personal stories of courtship

Click here to return to the welcome page of Courtship in America


Between 1708/9, when Samuel Gerrish courted Mary Sewall, and 1835, when Theodore Weld courted Angelina Grimke, the rituals of courtship underwent profound changes. Parental influence and involvement in the selection of their children's marriage partner visibly declined.

Book describing the joys of old-fashioned courtship
Young women and men were increasingly free to pick or reject a spouse with little parental interference. At the same time that courtship grew freer, however, marriage became an increasingly difficult transition point, particularly for women, and more and more women elected not to marry at all.

In seventeenth and early eighteenth century New England, courtship was not simply a personal, private matter. The law gave parents "the care and power...for the disposing of their Children in Marriage" and it was expected that they would take an active role overseeing their child's choice of a spouse. A father in Puritan New England had a legal right to determine which men would be allowed to court his daughters and a legal responsibility to give or withhold his consent from a child's marriage. A young man who courted a woman without her father's permission might be sued for inveigling the woman's affections.

Parental involvement in courtship was expected because marriage was not merely an emotional relationship between individuals but also a property arrangement among families. A young man was expected to bring land or some other form of property to a marriage while a young woman was expected to bring a dowry worth about half as much.

Wooden sculpture of a shotgun wedding showing pregnant bride, weeping mother and angry father

In most cases, Puritan parents played little role in the actual selection of a spouse (although Judge Sewall did initiate the courtship between his son Joseph and a neighbor named Elizabeth Walley). Instead, they tended to influence the timing of marriage. Since Puritan children were expected to bring property to marriage, and Puritans fathers were permitted wide discretion in when they distributed property to their children, many sons and daughters remained economically dependent for years, delaying marriages until a relatively late age.

Return to top

Credits:
Sculpture entitled "Shotgun Wedding" by Andy Anderson used with kind permission of the Stark Museum of Art
All other images/ from the Library of Congress