Digital
History>eXplorations>Lynching>Anti-Lynching
Legislation of the 1920s>William Borah's Letter to the
Editor of The Boston Transcript
William Borah's Letter to the Editor of The Boston Transcript
(June 8, 1922)
Source:
William Borah Papers, Library of Congress
"My
dear Mr. Editor, is it not apparent that the great problem which
confronts us in constitutional government is that of a redistribution
of power between the State and the national government –
shall the national government be authorized to take over the police
power of the State in whole, or in part? There is no dodging the
question. If the people of this nation want to redistribute the
powers of the government, let's face the question through a constitutional
amendment and put an end to this constant pressure upon the constitution.
For twenty years we have been compromising with our oath and passing
child labor laws – all in vain. The child is not yet subject
to the jurisdiction of the Federal government. Do the people want
to transfer unquestionably the power to Congress to deal with
this subject – if so, let the insane be met openly and intelligently,
and I trust with great deliberation. If we take the police power
of the State to protect the child from the exploitation in industry,
will it not also be found advantageous to give the Federal government
the power to see that the child is properly educated? Will the
State, which is incapable or unwilling to protect the child physically
be fit, or willing, do you think to look after its mental and
moral development. And if the State is unfit to protect the child,
the coming citizen, from cruel and unusual hours of labor, will
you still leave to the state the role right and power to protect
the life of a citizen against the attacks of the mob? If you want
to deal with the Federal government the power to reach the individuals
who compose the mob? Is it not a vain and ineffective thing to
try to deal with the subject by visiting punishment upon an officer
alone?"
|